New head coach Mel Tucker’s first game shows challenges are apparent after Michigan State football team loses to lowly Rutgers, which hadn’t won in Big 10 since 2017

Michigan State head coach Mel Tucker stands among his players during the second half against Rutgers on Saturday in East Lansing. (AP photo)

If anyone doubted the challenge facing new Michigan State coach Mel Tucker, it should be obvious now.

The Spartans began the season at home against Rutgers last weekend — perhaps the easiest game on their schedule, in theory — and lost 38-27. It was the first Big Ten win for the Scarlet Knights since 2017 and left Michigan State with basically no silver linings heading into its big rivalry game at Michigan this weekend.

“This is the beginning. It’s not the end. So we’re looking to make progress every day, and work really hard,” said Tucker, who took over in February after Mark Dantonio’s retirement. “You usually make quite a bit of improvement from the first game to the second game, and that’s something that we’re looking to do.”

Michigan State’s news conferences Tuesday focused largely on the upcoming game against Michigan. In that sense, the Spartans are fortunate to have that matchup on deck — it allows them to move on quickly from the ugly loss. But Michigan State did not look in any way ready to face its biggest rival, and the Wolverines are favored by over three touchdowns.

Tucker seemed uninterested in calling Michigan by its name — instead using “the school down the road” — but if the Spartans still have a lot they need to fix.

Michigan State turned the ball over seven times in the opener. Some of those looked like the result of carelessness instead of Rutgers pressure — so the Spartans should be able to clean that up — but Michigan State looked a long way from being able to put together extended stretches of mistake-free football.

“I think there’s a little bit of a mental side to it, with the new staff and the new offense, but ultimately, it just comes down to holding onto the ball,” quarterback Rocky Lombardi said.

It was hard to evaluate Michigan State’s defense at times, since Rutgers started with several short fields, and Lombardi did throw for 319 yards amid all those turnovers.

“I think we only punted twice,” Lombardi said.

A bigger concern was Michigan State’s inability to establish a consistent running game despite plenty of attempts. A couple fourth-down runs were stopped short, and Jordan Simmons had the highest yards-per-carry average on the team at just 3.1.

That’s not a good sign heading into the Michigan game. In that series, controlling the line of scrimmage is often crucial.

“One thing that’s very important to be able to handle is, if in fact you do lose a game, how do you handle a loss?” Tucker said. “What is your mental disposition coming off of a game like that?”


Today's breaking news and more in your inbox

I'm interested in (please check all that apply)

Starting at $4.75/week.

Subscribe Today