Eight Alger Correctional Facility staff charged in 2019 inmate death

LANSING — Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel today charged eight former and current employees of Alger Correctional Facility in Munising with felony counts related to the 2019 in-custody death of former inmate Jonathan Lancaster. Facing charges are four registered nurses who attended to Lancaster in his final days, two corrections officers present at his time of death, and both the former Acting Warden Scott Sprader and Assistant Deputy Warden Benny Mercier.

The state alleges that Lancaster ceased eating and drinking while incarcerated at Alger Correctional Facility and was placed in an observation cell and in restraints. He remained in the observation cell and restrained until he died three days later. Despite weight loss in excess of 50 pounds in 15 days, widespread knowledge of his deteriorating state, and Michigan Department of Corrections policies, Lancaster received no emergency medical attention until after his death.

“This death was a preventable tragedy that played out over days and under the defendants’ supervision,” Nessel said in a statement. “These are serious, and numerous, charges that reflect the broad culpability the defendants shoulder in the death of Johnathan Lancaster. The eight defendants had a responsibility for the care and well-being of those in their custody, and my office will continue to rigorously pursue accountability when that is not met.”

The charges issued today are as follows:

Former Acting Warden Scott Sprader