Breaking News
Front Page News

Marquette County Board votes to schedule CAD work session

Approves up to $100,000 in legal fees for Derocha

By ANNIE LIPPERT 5 min read

MARQUETTE -- On Tuesday night, the Marquette County Board met and discussed the ongoing CAD 911 system selection process. During the meeting, Commissioner Margaret Brumm gave a lengthy presentation on the Motorola and Tyler Technologies systems, including a summary of ongoing litigation against Tyler.

Brumm also shared that the presentation by Tyler in front of the county board that had been scheduled for Nov. 9 had been cancelled by Tyler Technologies.

At the end of her presentation, Brumm recommended to the board that they hold a work session to discuss the drawbacks and merits of both systems before their Dec. 1 meeting. She also recommended that the county consider hiring a manager of change position to help facilitate the transition.

The board voted unanimously to schedule the meeting and to look into a manager of change position, and Acting Chairperson Bill Nordeen asked Brumm to also look into ongoing litigation against Motorola.

Later in the meeting, during the second public comment period, Marquette County Undersheriff Lowell Larson addressed Brumm, saying that "through FOIA, a document was found where you sent an invoice to the county board for 51 hours at $300 an hour for a total of 15,300 to review documents and stuff (related to the CAD systems)."

Brumm responded that "Long before I was on the board, Commissioner (Fred) Benzie reached out to me before the holiday weekend with a couple of documents. One was from the consultant and one was from one of the other groups, and (Benzie) said, 'Can you help me understand this?'

"…I took the weekend on my own, and I looked through them and I sent him an email, and I think I sent it to all the board. At the time, I wasn’t on the board ... I just said, 'These are the most complicated, difficult documents to understand whatsoever' ... Well, then we went back and forth on some more questions.

"And then I thought, you know, I’m doing a little bit of work here. It’s very interesting. It’s kind of fun. Maybe I should send an invoice in and see if I get paid ... I’m also willing to testify in front of a notary that I never got paid for that invoice.

"…So, if all of you were worried about me getting paid by the county for my statements, I was not."

Benzie also addressed the issue, saying that "I think everybody in this room knows I don’t have the authority to hire legal counsel on behalf of Marquette County."

In addition to the CAD 911, the county board unanimously approved up to $100,000 in county money towards Chairperson Joe Derocha's potential legal fees relating to an ongoing investigation by the Michigan State Police. Derocha was not present at the meeting.

Benzie made the motion, saying "I move that the board, under MCL691.1408, authorize the county to pay for an attorney for Chairman Derocha of his choosing to represent him in the Michigan State Police investigation arising from his deposition testimony as chairman in the amount not to exceed $100,000 ... with council’s invoices to be redacted of confidential information and submitted to the county administrator for payment and that the board find the chairman was acting on behalf of the county and within the scope of his authority when he gave that testimony.

"I further move that the board express its continued confidence in and support for Chairman Derocha and its respect for the investigative process."

Benzie clarified that he did not expect the fees to reach $100,000, stating, "I don't believe it's going to cost anywhere near that much."

The investigation has to do with a deposition Derocha made on Sept. 11 of this year as a part of the ongoing litigation between the county and Kubick Aviation. In his deposition, Derocha alleged that he was physically threatened by Mark Hangen, who is also a party in the lawsuit, before a Nov. 25 2025 meeting of the County Board. Hangen claims he was not at that meeting, and that he never physically threatened Derocha.

Hangen spoke via Zoom during the meeting's second public comment period, stating, "(I) Just want to make clear I’m not going after Joe Derocha, and I’m not suing Joe Derocha. I want you to understand (that) the state of Michigan is investigating him for potentially felony perjury, yet to be proven.

"And so, what you’ve approved is up to $100,000 to defend him against the state of Michigan. Could be the prosecuting attorney down in Traverse City where (the deposition) occurred. Or it could be the Michigan attorney general’s ethics unit. But it’s not me, guys. (I'm) Just letting you know you’re funding this against the state of Michigan."

In an October email to The Mining Journal, Hangen indicated that he filed the original complaint against Derocha with MSP on Oct. 18.

While no commissioners addressed the MSP investigation during the commissioner comment period, Nordeen did circle back to the CAD 911 issue, stating that "maybe what we ought to do is just stay with Central Square for a couple more years and save the county all kinds of money, and then we don’t have to worry about Tyler or Motorola. Maybe that’s our answer.

"But at the end of the day, we will figure our way forward, and Marquette County will still be operating, and Central Dispatch will still be fielding calls, and our firefighters and EMS will still be going out there and helping people in the community."

The next regular meeting of the Marquette County Commission is at 6 p.m. on Dec. 1in room 231 of the county courthouse.

Starting at /week.