Red rallied from a 3-0 deficit and scored two unanswered goals midway through the second half to prevail 5-4 over Blue.
Kathleen Grizzel scored three goals for Red, including the game-tying marker. Gina Fielding scored early in the second half and Imari McKinney Jr. notched the game-winner.
Emily Markle had two goals for the Blue team, one coming on a penalty kick.
Sterling Wright and Faith Perala also had goals, while Wright and Deni Peterson each recorded an assist.
Alli Vanwelsenaers made seven saves in goal for Blue.
Blue Djibouti beat the Ninja Turtles, 3-2, as Dustin Burkman scored twice and Anna Massaro added a single tally.
Colin Gaffney scored two goals for the Ninja Turtles.