Cold, hard cash

MARQUETTE - Cash or credit? For many - who have already maxed out their credit cards or are just trying to manage their spending better in the tough economy - the answer is increasingly the old-fashioned one.

Both national and local retailers have noticed a shift away from credit cards in favor of cash and debit cards. A big factor is less credit available as major card issuers cut spending limits and raise fees even for customers who pay their bills on time.

Lee LaForge, manager of Book World in Marquette, said he has seen a noticeable increase in the use of debit cards. He said debit card transactions represent about 80 percent of the store's sales.

"I've seen a big increase," he said. "For a while when people came in they would ask 'Do you accept debit cards?' Now it's just a given."

Bill Brazier, general manager of the Marquette Food Co-op, said he has also seen an increase in the number of people using debit cards over credit cards.

Stuart Baker, a financial counselor with GreenPath Debt Solutions in Marquette, said he's advised people to use debit cards instead of credit cards for a while but only recently has he seen an increase in the practice.

"We've advised people to stop living on their credit cards and using something like a debit card in place of running up more debt," he said. "Obviously if you use a debit card or cash to buy things you're not paying interest to the bank, you're using your own money to pay for things."

Baker said there are some disadvantages to using debit cards. Depending on the level of security you pay for, debit cards are generally less protected than credit cards, he said. If someone gets ahold of the PIN number for your debit card they can wipe out your bank account.

He said sometimes people overspend when using debit or credit cards because they can't physically see the money leaving their wallet. However, he said using cash is also a risk.

"There's no protection when it comes to cash. If you lose your wallet you lose the money," he said. "But if someone steals your debit card, they may not know the PIN number and you have time to notify the bank."

National retailers like Wal-Mart Stores Inc., Target Corp. and J.C. Penney Co. have also noticed the trend of consumers financing their purchases with cash or debit cards over credit cards.

The shift ends Americans' long love affair with credit cards and is one of the changes in consumer behavior that has emerged since the financial meltdown that could depress consumer spending this holiday season and affect shoppers' habits long afterward.

Particularly during holiday seasons past, shoppers could count on a pile of plastic to give them the extra financing needed to splurge on presents before they had to face the bills in January or later.

But even when the economy recovers and credit loosens up, analysts say Americans - shaped by what could be a deep and long-lasting recession - are likely to stick with buying only what they can afford just as their parents or grandparents did after the Great Depression.

''I think this is a new way of life,'' said Robert Smith, of Loves Park, Ill., who along with his wife has been using cash and debit cards to finance their spending, including vacations, since they paid off their credit card debts in July. ''I like to be able to know that we paid for something. I hate monthly payments when you use a credit card.''

Smith, who has four children ages 7 to 13 and owns a motivational training company called Drive and Grow Rich, says his business is down 20 percent this year, and since he is saddled with a mortgage, he doesn't want to get back into debt.

While the credit crunch is teaching consumers to be more ''financially prudent,'' it's creating a lot of pain for both consumers and stores, said Curtis Arnold, founder of CreditRatings.com.

One sign of how strapped consumers are for credit - and buying only what they have the cash for - is that for the first time in 17 years, Penney's has seen swings in spending around payday cycles over the past three months.

That's common for discounters like Wal-Mart, but a rarity for a mall-based department store - suggesting that Penney's middle-income customers are feeling the pinch as well. Penney's President and Chief Merchandising Officer Ken Hicks noted that the chain hasn't seen swings in spending around payday since about 1991, when the U.S. was entering a recession.

At Wal-Mart, the volatility in spending around payday - a drop in spending in the days before, is followed by spending bursts right afterward.

- has become even more pronounced since September. Chief Financial Officer Tom Schoewe told The Associated Press that shoppers are now unable to buy even necessities in the few days before payday.

Such swings became more dramatic last fall, but subsided when shoppers received their government rebate checks this past spring.

Eduardo Castro-Wright, president and chief executive of Wal-Mart's U.S. division, told investors last month that credit card payments as a percentage of total payments fell 7.4 percent so far in the current fiscal year, which ends in January. That's a big reversal from the robust double-digit growth rates in credit cards over the past three years, he said.

Target executives told investors late last month that it's seeing lower credit card usage among its shoppers for the first time since 2001-2003.

At Penney's, Hicks said that use of the company's store credit card was flat during the third quarter. The use of credit cards issued by other parties declined by a couple of percentage points as a percentage of overall payment, he noted, while cash was up by the same amount. Hicks said he hasn't seen a decline in credit card use in five or six years.

Scott Hoyt, senior director of consumer economics at Moody's Economy.com. said that Federal Reserve data has never shown an annual decline in credit card use, but he acknowledged that there isn't any solid payment data. Visa Inc. said that debit card growth is coming at the expense of cash and checks versus credit cards. And MasterCard Worldwide said consumers are increasingly paying with plastic - debit or credit - at the expense of cash and check, but didn't break out which portion was debit cards.

But many Americans are using cash or debit cards because they are being forced to. Laura Nishikawa, an analyst at Innovest Strategic Value Advisors Inc., a New York investment research firm, said that based on data from Visa, Master Card and American Express, the number of credit cards that consumers have fell 5 percent in the second quarter from the first quarter. That was mainly because consumers received fewer credit card offers, she said.

For years, consumers tapped into inflated home equity and used credit cards to finance their spending. Now those spigots are being shut off, and job losses are mounting.

''Consumers are really struggling to find sources of cash to make purchases,'' Hoyt said. ''The rapid job losses are taking a big bite out of labor incomes. Obviously, it's making it much more difficult to borrow.''

Online jewelry seller Blue Nile, which reported a 23 percent drop in third-quarter profits earlier this month, noted that deteriorating credit has hurt sales of jewelry priced from $5,000 to $25,000.

Doug Scovanner, Target's chief financial officer, told investors on Nov. 17 after disappointing third-quarter results that credit tightening across all U.S. card issuers ''has already had a very important adverse effect on our sales, and I'm sure it will continue to do so.''

Target is further tightening finance terms for its card holders as it confronts increasing defaults, and has promised investors that it will become even more stringent if credit conditions keep getting worse.

But Target and other stores are finding themselves in the awkward position of wanting to tighten their credit terms to protect profits while at the same time realizing that such moves could depress spending, Arnold said. So many stores are dangling generous interest-free finance offers and offering deep discounts of up to 20 percent if you apply for a credit card, he said.

Target is offering a 10 percent discount for new credit card holders, while Bluenile.com has teamed up with Bill Me Later to let customers delay payments for 90 days on purchases of $250 or more.

But don't expect Smith, the entrepreneur, to bite. He's sticking with his $2,000 holiday budget, much lower than the $6,000 he spent last year on gifts. He added that he and his wife are setting aside the holiday money in a separate account so they won't go over budget.

And James Coyne, a 27-year-old full-time college student from Grand Forks, N.D., recently bought an engagement ring at a small jewelry store for $3,000 in cash because he doesn't want to rack up any debt.

''I have heard all these horror stories,'' said Coyne. ''I save my money until I can afford it.''